Theater Review: 'Darling Grenadine' a risky romantic comedy
By Kathryn A. McCord on July 8, 2019 - Northwest Herald
"Nick Cosgrove’s Paul carries a large amount of the show’s pathos on his shoulders and believably grounds the narrative in reality. While Saunders’ and Thomas’ roles get to indulge in occasional flights of fancy on stage, Cosgrove is tasked with the somewhat thankless job of portraying a character who must live firmly in the real world of consequences, which he does with exquisite depth and heart. While he doesn’t have as many opportunities to wow the audience in song as his costars, when he does get the chance, he is sensational."
Marriott’s ‘Darling Grenadine’ is shaken, not stirred—and a profound story of addiction and recovery
by Quinn Rigg on July 9, 2019 - Chicagoland Musical Theatre
"Harry’s brother Paul (powerfully portrayed by Nick Cosgrove) struggles to cope with his brother’s addiction...Nick Cosgrove’s performance as Paul (the human) is a perfect foil for Saunders’ Harry. Honest and reserved, Cosgrove sheds light on the world of a grieving family. Through his convincing justifications and desperate pleading, Cosgrove elicits sympathy for a real person struggling to hold on to the things that hurt him."
Making Problems Easier to Swallow
by Colin Douglas on July 8, 2019 - Chicago Theatre Review
"Nick Cosgrove is magnificent as Harry’s bartending brother, Paul. Gifted with one of the most sublime voices to be heard on any stage...He’s one of the best reasons for seeing this new show."
by Al Bresloff on July 8, 2019 - Around the Town Chicago
"Harry was raised by his best friend Paul (deftly handled by Nick Cosgrove) and his family...Cosgrove as Paul the Human is a delight to watch and his character is a solid one who has stayed with his buddy and taken on whatever he has asked him to be, not for himself, but for Harry and the sake of their friendship."
PicksInSix Review: DARLING GRENADINE Marriott Theatre
by Ed Tracy on July 9, 2019 - PicksInSix
"The rich and well-defined characters in Harry’s orbit include Paul–a role in which Nick Cosgrove shines—whose family took in Harry and who Paul has treated like an older brother throughout his life."
Marriott's 'Darling Grenadine' serves up bittersweet tale of addiction
by Barbara Vitello on July 10, 2019 - Daily Herald
"Observing their romance is Harry's longtime human pal Paul (a top-notch, nicely circumspect Nick Cosgrove), who runs the bar that Harry finances and where he plays piano."
New Musical ‘Darling Grenadine’ a Sobering Look at the Quest for Happiness
by Hedy Weiss on July 8, 2019 - WTTW Chicago Tonight
"Cosgrove is ideally intense, likeable and understated as the well-balanced Paul, who is eventually able to free himself of a certain co-dependency with Harry."
New Marriott musical is spellbinding
by Jodie Jacobs on July 9, 2019 - Chicago Theater and Arts
"Nick Cosgrove...is excellent as Paul, whose family raised Harry and who needs finance help from Harry for bar renovations."
by Colin Douglas on November 16, 2018 - Chicago Theatre Review
"Cogsworth, the tightly wound head butler-turned-mantle clock, is impeccably played by the gifted Nick Cosgrove. Nick was last seen at Drury Lane in “Joseph…Dreamcoat,” “Rock of Ages” and “Saturday Night Fever,” but his talents have also taken him all over the country. The actor’s found his niche in this production."
A Magical Beauty and the Beast at Drury Lane Review
by Suzanne Magnuson on November 16, 2018 - Splash Magazines
"...and Nick Cosgrove as a perfectly stalwart Cogsworth."
Drury Lane's 'Beauty and the Beast' enchants despite staging missteps
by Caroline Linden on November 17, 2018 - Daily Herald
"...Cogsworth (the endearing Nick Cosgrove)..."
BWW Review: BEAUTY AND THE BEAST at Drury Lane Theatre
by Emily McClanathan on November 18, 2018 - BroadwayWorld Chicago
"Nick Cosgrove makes an excellent Cogsworth, the high-strung clock, and he delivers a well-timed stream of banter opposite Carter's Lumiere."
Drury Lane's Beauty and the Beast revival is showing its age
by Jack Helbig on December 3, 2019 - Chicago Reader
"The only believable couple in the show is Nick Cosgrove's too tightly wound Cogsworth and Tony Carter's adorably flirtatious Lumiere. Every time they stepped on stage, I found myself wishing I was at a new, as yet unwritten musical, centered on these two."
by Colin Douglas on September 9, 2017 - Chicago Theatre Review
"...Nick Cosgrove is hilarious as his flamboyant son Franz. Cosgrove's "Hit Me With Your Best Shot"...offers yet another comic highlight in this show."
'Rock of Ages' ranks as a timeless fun ticket
by Phil Potempa on September 12, 2017 - Post-Tribune
"Some of the funniest moments come from the scenes featuring Nick Cosgrove as Franz..."
Review: Drury Lane's ROCK OF AGES is the 80's Jukebox Musical Experience We Need This Fall
by Cory Davis on September 11, 2017 - The Hawk Chicago
"In perhaps the musical's best number, Tiffany Tatreau and Nick Cosgrove deliver the most entertaining and surprising rendition of "Hit Me With Your Best Shot" imaginable."
Drury Lane’s over the top ‘Rock of Ages’ is nothin’ but a good time
by Barry Reszel on September 10, 2017 - Chicagoland Musical Theatre
"Nick Cosgrove as his animated son Franz gets every last laugh out of the character, and then some."
by Alan Bresloff on September 12th, 2017 - Around The Town Chicago
"...and his son, Franz (the very comical Nick Cosgrove)..."
DRURY LANE'S "ROCK OF AGES" "AIN'T NOTHIN" BUT A GOOD TIME"
by Ken Payne on September 10th, 2017 - Buzz Center Stage
"...and Nick Cosgrove who nails the role of Franz, the flamboyant German son of developer Hertz, who draws a laugh in just about every scene he occupies."
Energetic 'Rock of Ages' revisits eighties music
by Reno Lovison on September 9th, 2017 - Chicago Theater and Arts
"...reluctantly aided by his cowering and outrageously funny son, Franz (Nick Cosgrove)..."
'Rock of Ages' is still nothin' but a good time at Drury Lane
by Chris Jones on September 10, 2017 - Chicago Tribune
"thanks to...Nick Cosgrove, it's at least a few ticks more fun than usual."
Review: 'Saturday Night Fever' not just a retro disco inferno
by Chris Jones on January 27th, 2017 - Chicago Tribune
"...the excellent Nick Cosgrove, the "Jersey Boys" actor who here plays Bobby..."
Striving to live the dream in 'Saturday Night Fever'
by Hedy Weiss on January 27th, 2017 - Chicago Sun-Times
"...the soulful, conflicted Bobby C, expertly played by Nick Cosgrove..."
Chicago Theatre Review – Disco Inferno
by Colin Douglas on January 28th, 2017 - Chicago Theatre Review
"...and, in an especially touching performance, Nick Cosgrove, as the insecure Bobby C."
Don't Miss 'Jersey Boys' at Forrest Theatre
by Sally Friedman on January 3rd, 2014 - SOUTH JERSEY LOCAL NEWS
"Because the role of Frankie Valli is so extraordinarily demanding, there are several actors who sometimes alternate the role. On a recent night, it was the extraordinary main Frankie, Nick Cosgrove, who did the honors, and left absolutely nothing to be desired. He is not only a consummate actor who handled the pathos of the boys in their rise, and his own personal losses, with a spot-on performance; Cosgrove also nails the difficult vocal demands magnificently."
Review: The effervescent 'Jersey Boys'
by Howard Shapiro on December 18th, 2013 - NEWSWORKS
"Lead singer Frankie Valli, is the boyish, deep-eyed Nick Cosgrove, who brings a brooding vulnerability to the role and sings Valli's trademark falsetto beautifully."
'Jersey Boys' is a 'Heck of a show'
by Bob Shryock on December 17, 2013 - SOUTH JERSEY TIMES
"Close your eyes and Cosgrove’s voice makes him Valli’s double — Valli’s voice is not easy to replicate."
Jersey Boys - National Tour - Forrest Theatre
by Neal Zoren on December 16, 2013 - NEALSPAPER
"Nick Cosgrove nails Frankie’s restlessness, wiriness, and innocence in Spring and grows to be a mature, assured Valli by Fall and Winter. It is the most easygoing performance of the four and so well executed, you barely realize how deftly Cosgrove has moved from one phase of Frankie’s life to another until he’s accomplished the transformation."
MMT Quick Review of ‘Jersey Boys: The Story of Frankie Valli & The Four Seasons’
by Thomasena Farrar on December 16th, 2013 - IJAZZGLOBAL
"The entire cast is remarkable, but I must say I thoroughly enjoyed Nick Cosgrove, who played Valli and sang a beautiful cover of “Moody’s Mood For Love” that had me swooning!"
Music remains vital in ‘Jersey Boys’
by Andrew S. Hughes on November 28, 2013 - SOUTH BEND TRIBUNE
"As in real life, Valli takes center stage in “Jersey Boys,” and Cosgrove does an effective job of showing the character’s progression from innocent, insecure teenager to confident performer and mature adult; he also has a strong falsetto voice that convincingly performs Valli’s vocal parts."
'Jersey Boys' at The Hippodrome Theatre
by Amanda Gunther on November 14th, 2013 - DC METRO THEATRE ARTS
"And the title man, Mr. Frankie Valli (Nick Cosgrove) has the voice of a pure angel. The range that he achieves in this production is sublime. Cosgrove’s big vocal moment of unadulterated success comes during “Can’t Take My Eyes Off of You” where the crowd goes absolutely wild for his pitch perfect crooning. His Jersey accent combined with his crazy splits and dance moves makes Cosgrove a triple threat, but as Valli— with an ‘i’— he weathers the worst season; proverbial winter. His familial struggles weigh heavily into his character and even change the emotional sound of his songs; a stunning transformation to behold. Cosgrove is perfect in this role, really bringing the spark and incredibly unique sound of Frankie Valli to life beyond compare."
Theater Review: Jersey Boys
by Chad Young on October 31st, 2013 - NASHVILLE PARENT MAGAZINE
"Dynamic on stage, Cosgrove is a vocal powerhouse who perfectly nails Valli’s signature falsetto range. While it’s hard to select a true favorite because all of the songs are so amazing, there’s no denying that Cosgrove’s solo, “Can’t Take My Eyes Off You,” is a true standout that allows him to showcase his full range of his talent."
'Jersey Boys' even better second time around
by Julie McHale on October 24th, 2013 - GMTODAY TIMEOUT
"Cosgrove is a knock-out singer as Valli. He also underlines Valli’s inability to strike a balance in his life."
'Jersey Boys' stands out as the musical putting audiences on their feet
by Emily Carl on October 19th, 2013 - THE EXAMINER MILWAUKEE
"Each of the four men suited their roles extremely well, but it was clearly Cosgrove's show as he showed incredible acting and vocal range. His exceptional falsetto combined with charisma and personality drew attention during each of the four seasons. "
Joyful "Jersey Boys" hits all the right notes
by Matt Mueller on October 19th, 2013 - ONMILWAUKEE.COM
"A Four Seasons musical needs to have a solid Frankie Valli, and Cosgrove fits the bill. He's got the lovely crooner's voice down pat, and his falsetto suitably soars."
Oh what a run - 'Jersey Boys' is most successful show since Palace reopened nine years ago
by Brynn Mandel on October 15th, 2013 - THE REPUBLICAN AMERICAN
"As the song ended, the audience and the actor shared a moment. He belted a big, final falsetto note. One by one, the audience rose until nearly the entire sold-out orchestra and balcony sections stood, clapping and cheering. Beneath the spotlight, Nick Cosgrove, a Chicago native channeling singing icon Frankie Valli in the touring musical "Jersey Boys," gazed past the fourth wall. He paused, misty eyed, patting a palm over his heart."
Palace's 'Jersey Boys' superb
by Joanne Greco Rochman on October 11th, 2013 - THE REPUBLICAN AMERICAN
"And then there's Nick Cosgrove as Frankie Valli. Of all the singers playing the role, Cosgrove lives up to Tommy's description of the "voice of an angel." When you hear Cosgrove's falsetto as crystal clear as the chandeliers in the Palace lobby, you know you're not listening to just another Valli stand-in."
'Jersey Boys’ brings the story of the Four Seasons back to Columbus
by Erin Millar on September 21st, 2013 - THE EXAMINER COLUMBUS
"Cosgrove has a phenomenal vocal range, bringing the voice of Frankie Valli to the popular musical."
BWW Reviews: JERSEY BOYS Offers Rare Insight to Four Seasons' Path to the Top
by Paul Batterson on September 19th, 2013 - BROADWAYWORLD
"Finally Valli (Nick Cosgrove, who handles Valli's falsetto flawlessly) relives the final days of the original band and how he and Gaudio strove to keep the band alive to pay off the debts incurred by DeVito."
Show review - “Jersey Boys,” through Sept. 8 at the WAC
by Kevin Kinder on September 4th, 2013 - NWA: THE SOURCE
"Cosgroves’ run as Valli was particularly wonderful, and not just for his vocal performance, which accurately scrapes the hard-to-fathom highs and power of Valli’s legendary falsetto. His takes on Valli’s stubborness, and his failings outside of the structure of the band, pull audience members into uncomfortable locations."
Let's Hear It For the 'Jersey Boys'
by Neil Shurley on July 12th, 2013 - THE GREENVILLE NEWS
"Nick Cosgrove, as Frankie Valli, has a fantastic voice, a dynamic presence and pays great tribute to a true show biz legend."
Can't take my eyes off of Jersey Boys at the Capitol Theatre
By Callie Oppedisano on June 7th, 2013 - UTAH THEATRE BLOGGERS
"Finally, the voice of the Four Seasons, Frankie Valli narrates the final leg of the show. Played by Nick Cosgrove, who gives an impressive transformation of Valli from youthfulness to maturity, Valli’s story perhaps best communicates the heartbreak of lost relationships among families at home and families on the road. So, too, however Cosgrove fully imparts Valli’s love of the music, a theme at the core of Jersey Boys. Cosgrove carries the major burden as Valli, who had one of the most distinct voices of the twentieth century, but he does so ably, imparting the quality of Valli’s signature intonation without trying to mimic exactly."
'Jersey Boys' features four quality leads
By Erica Hansen on June 6th, 2013 - DESERET NEWS
"Nick Cosgrove tips his hat beautifully to the recognizable falsetto sound of Valli. He soars on the top notes but really stands out with the softer “My Eyes Adored You” and “Fallen Angel.” With more than 30 songs in the show and Cosgrove singing the lead on most, it’s no small task to tackle that music, eight shows a week. And he appears to be loving every minute of it."
'Jersey Boys' showcases The Four Seasons in Utah premiere
By QSaltLake Staff on June 6th, 2013 - GAY SALT LAKE
"While the production was very well executed and nary was a note missed, it was Cosgrove as Frankie Valli that stole the show at Salt Lake City’s opening night of the three-week stay. He brought down the house imitating the distinct falsetto of Valli and harmonized perfectly with the other singers. "
Jersey Boys Dazzles in Salt Lake City
By Marsha Maxwell on June 6th, 2013 - SLC ABOUT.COM
"Where Jersey Boys really shines is, of course, in the singing. Cosgrove was nearly flawless in the role of Frankie Valli, which has been known to ravage a singer's voice."
'Jersey Boys' offers up the Four Seasons' tunnel vision to stardom
By Ben Fulton on June 6th, 2013 - THE SALT LAKE TRIBUNE
"Frankie Valli, played from convincing top to persuasive bottom by Nick Cosgrove, comes across as ever the frustrated gentleman, ready to please but almost aching to somehow fail."
By Charles Jarrett on March 20th, 2013 - ROSSMOOR NEWS
"Cosgrove and his partners do a great job of capturing the group's sound and making you feel as if you are seeing the real Four Seasons."
Jersey Boys Comes Roaring Back to San Francisco
by Richard Connema on March 19th, 2013 - SF TALKIN BROADWAY
"However, the real source of the show's power is the songs, especially with the wailing falsetto voice of Nick Cosgrove as Frankie Valli. His voice has a powerful effect on the ballads "My Eyes Adored You" and "Can't Take My Eyes Off You." He is energetic and dedicated and he handles the demands of the show excitingly."
Can't Take Eyes Off 'Jersey Boys'
by Leslie Katz on March 19th, 2013 - SF EXAMINER
"Nick Cosgrove, whose vocals are commanding, takes the reins as Frankie Valli, whose famed falsetto arguably was the primary defining factor of the group and a primary reason for its hits."
Four Seasons musical "Jersey Boys" great way to start Spring
by Kevin M. Thomas on March 18th, 2013 - SF EXAMINER
"The show is lead by Nick Cosgrove as Valli and he is in great form playing the iconic singer, who is able to show Valli's true sweetness with his own beautiful voice."
'Jersey Boys' Struts Into San Francisco
March 18th, 2013 - CBS SAN FRANCISCO
"Nick Cosgrove is impressive as the lead singer Frankie Valli, hitting those high notes with ease."
Valli's boys stellar in return to the Curran
by Lanz Christian Banes on March 15th, 2013 - SF TIMES HERALD
"The actors truly channel the essence of the Four Seasons, with Cosgrove's impressive falsetto and deft transitions to dialogue hearken back to the real Frankie Valli."
Jersey Boys in San Francisco
by Diana Vergara on March 15th, 2013 - CALTV ENTERTAINMENT
"Nick Cosgrove rightfully cast as Frankie Valli successfully portrays the youth and innocence of a teenage Frankie as his transitions into a big star. The actor surpassed his natural “youngish” look on stage as he transforms into an older Frankie Valli fruitfully."
Those Boys from Jersey Man, Can They Sing! JERSEY BOYS Rocks the Curran Theatre
by Linda Hodges on March 15th, 2013 - BWW SAN FRANCISCO
"Cosgrove dives right into the Frankie Valli falsetto, making the trip down memory lane feel like it was just yesterday. He imbibes his character with heart which is a good thing because Frankie goes through the most changes in the show. He starts out as a young teenager who still has a curfew, and before you know it he's married with kids of his own."
'Jersey Boys' hits all the right notes in Boston
by Juliet Pennington on February 4th, 2013 - THE SUN CHRONICLE
"Nick Cosgrove played Valli and was wonderful. Belting out five-octave songs night-after-night can't be easy, but he made it look - and sound - effortless."
'The Boys' are a welcome sight at The Colonial
by Rich Fahey on February 3rd, 2013 - BOSTON STAGES
"Nick Cosgrove as Valli has a tough act to follow in Joseph Leo Bwarie, who played the role in the two previous visits to Boston, but Cosgrove is a strong actor and succeeds in channeling Valli’s almost-impossible-to-duplicate soaring falsettos."
Theatre: Jersey Boys
by Robert Israel on February 3rd, 2013 - EDGE BOSTON
"Nick Cosgrove performs with athletic prowess, including a scene where he does a split on stage that had some members of the audience audibly gasping."
Frankie Valli & The Four Seasons Live Again: The Tony-winning Musical is Back in Boston
by Jim Sullivan on February 3rd, 2013 - JIMSULLIVANINK
"It doesn’t hurt that Valli (who in real life is now 78) is played terrifically by Nick Cosgrove, and the same goes for other guys. I’m talking acting and singing."
Boston Broadway Recants The Story of Music Greatness with Jersey Boys Opening
by Kellie Speed on February 1st, 2013 - JUSTLUXE
"Nick Cosgrove’s performance of Frankie Valli was impeccable, reaching pitches that otherwise only Valli himself could achieve."
'Jersey Boys' is electrifying journey to yesteryear
by Tom Alvarez on January 14th, 2012 - INDIANAPOLIS EXAMINER
"Nick Cosgrove was particularly impressive singing in a falsetto voice that nicely replicated that of Valli, and at times seemed to surpass, at least in range, that of the icon he played."
'Jersey Boys' is a Knockout
by Jenn McKee on December 20th, 2012 - PRIDE SOURCE
"Cosgrove is a knockout, with vocals that soar."
Jersey-mania is back
by Daniel Skora on December 20th, 2012 - ENCORE MICHIGAN
"Cosgrove impressively replicates Valli's strong falsetto."
The original Jersey Shore in Detroit with musical "Jersey Boys"
by Samantha White on December 18th, 2012 - THE OAKLAND PRESS
"The enthusiastic cast received prolonged applause several times from an audience that hung on every note the amazingly talented Nick Cosgrove, as Valli, belted out. Cosgrove’s singing is a vocal adventure of gorgeous vibrato, sharp notes and impressive key changes."
Aronoff Hosts Broadway Production 'Jersey Boys'
by Emily Begley on December 4th, 2012 - THE NEWS RECORD
"One of the band’s most distinguished aspects was lead singer Frankie Valli’s three-octave range — an extremely difficult feat to match. Cosgrove delivered a flawless performance Valli would have been proud of. He perfectly hit even the highest of notes and the unique quality of his voice captivated audience members with each song."
Recreation of a Rock-and-Roll Hall of Fame band lives up to expectations
by Rick Pender on December 1st, 2012 - CITYBEAT
"As Valli, Nick Cosgrove has the requisite three-octave vocal range to hit the high notes. He has a wonderfully smooth delivery (his rendition of “Can’t Take My Eyes Off You” will melt a lot of hearts), as well as the intense physical presence (he even does the splits) that marked Valli as the group’s step-out star."
Musical Review: Jersey Boys
by Leah Zipperstein on December 1st, 2012 - iSPYCINCY
"Now let’s get to Frankie, who, as in the real story, is also the star of the show. Portrayed by Nick Cosgrove, there’s no denying his voice is special. He’s got three octaves of range that make the girls swoon and the guys jealous. When Cosgrove is tasked to belt out “Can’t Take My Eyes Off Of You,” the audience overflows in applause because it is – pun intended – just too good to be true. Cosgrove teamed with the rest of this stellar cast are nothing short of pitch perfect."
'Jersey Boys': Oh! What a musical
by Philip Balistriere on November 12th, 2012 - THE BADGER HERALD
"Cosgrove belts out the songs and hits those famous high notes with as much believability as possible."
High-energy Jersey Boys strings together the Four Seasons' Hits at Overture Hall
by Jennifer A. Smith on November 11th, 2012 - THE DAILY PAGE
"The biggest draw here is the exceptional voice of lead performer Nick Cosgrove as Frankie Valli. Cosgrove’s voice is an impressive instrument whose power doesn’t flag during the show’s 33 songs."
'Jersey Boys' a look behind the limelight
by Tracy Poindexter-Canton on October 22nd, 2012 - THE SPOKESMAN REVIEW
"As Valli and DeVito, Cosgrove and Gardiner provide impactful narrations as polar opposites. Valli is mature, loyal and remorseful, while DeVito is ruthless, self-serving and destructive. Cosgrove embodies Valli’s petite stature and signature falsetto, greatly complemented by the satiny baritone, bass and tenor vocals of Gardiner, Lomenda and Jacoby."
Jersey Boys musical a polished package full of humour, fun
by Stephanie McKay on October 1st, 2012 - THE STARPHOENIX
"Nick Cosgrove stars as Valli and his voice is the star of the show. The singer's range is stunning and he's perfected that falsetto that made Valli famous. It's great to have the story, but with Cosgrove at the helm the show could get away with doing nothing more than covering these classic songs."
Jersey Boys - Magical! Dazzling! ...smitten
by Jay Catterson on September 8th, 2012 - THE CHARLEBOIS POST
"Nick Cosgrove is the perfect package as Valli; armed with good looks, he nails those astronomical falsetto notes whilst delivering a humble, genuine take on Valli's character as a loyal, yet emotionally conflicted man."
Jersey Boy balances the music with its story
by Mark Robins on September 8th, 2012 - GAY VANCOUVER
"Nick Cosgrove literally shines as the singer with “the voice of an angel” as comfortable in the high notes as he is in Valli’s later years that saw some of that falsetto sound disappear."
Jersey Boys at the Queen Elizabeth Theatre
by Laura Murray on September 6th, 2012 - VANCOUVER PUBLIC RELATIONS
"At the helm, in the role of Frankie Valli, is the immensely gifted young performer Nick Cosgrove. Having completed a mandatory six weeks of training at ‘Camp Frankie,’ he absolutely inhabits the part. With his clear-as-a-bell tone and chill-inducing falsetto, one could easily forget they were watching a play and not the Frankie Valli."
Jersey Boys - the rise and fall of a pop sensation
by Anna Boroweicki on August 22nd, 2012 - ST. ALBERT GAZETTE
"In this Broadway touring production, Nick Cosgrove, a young star in the making, plays Frankie Valli, the superstar hero whose falsetto took The Four Seasons into the big time. At last Friday night’s production, the crowd completely bought Cosgrove as Valli from his early teen years landing a spot with a band to his middle-age years when he tragically loses his daughter to a drug overdose. His performance was so authentic the audience forgot Cosgrove wasn’t Valli. And when he sang the confection Sherry and his trademark song, the 1967 lounge ballad Can’t Take My Eyes Off of You, the crowd went wild."
Jersey Boys: Oh What A Night!
by Colin Maclean on August 17th, 2012 - EDMONTON SUN
"The show stands or falls on the performances of the four actors who play the unreformed street hood Tommy DeVito (John Gardiner), the gifted songwriter Bob Gaudio (Preston Truman Boyd — good singer/great actor), Nick Massi — always the outsider (Michael Lomenda) and Frankie Valli (Nick Cosgrove — impressive with a soaring falsetto voice). They are outstanding, channeling The Four Seasons but in the theatrical version they can move beyond the limited sound of the records of the day to create thrilling builds and ringing chords."
Jersey Boys - a slick, soulful show
by Liz Nicholls on August 16th, 2012 - EDMONTON JOURNAL
"Nick Cosgrove gives us a thrilling evocation of the voice that planted them in the public consciousness (and the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame)."
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat at the New Theatre
by Robert Trussell on July 1st, 2011 - THE KANSAS CITY STAR
"Nick Cosgrove is an appropriately appealing Joseph - innocent, good hearted and a bit arrogant at times.
Cosgrove knows how to charm an audience and he possesses a terrific pop-opera voice."
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat twists a classic
by Grace Suh on July 5th, 2011 - THE PITCH
"Joseph is played by the passably Hebraic-looking hunk Nick Cosgrove, who does a great young, bright and oblivious. His voice is just gorgeous. And he's one of those dancers who not only is an extraordinary mover but also looks like he's having a blast."
Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat captivates at New Theatre
by Nancy Pistorius on July 14th, 2011 - THE EXAMINER
"Nick Cosgrove is an energetic, charismatic Joseph, and he shines in every scene."
Muny's "Titanic" is a big production with little heart
by Judith Newmark on July 6th, 2010 - STLToday
"As the lookout Frederick Fleet, Nick Cosgrove endows "No Moon" with vivid emotion, particular to his time and place."